
The Cignetti Recipe Part 3: The Players
By Steve Sturm - IlliniGuys Football Analyst
January 26, 2026
(Cover photo courtesy Hoosier Huddle)
Welcome to Part 3 of the Cignetti Recipe. Now that I've done a deep dive on Curt Cignetti and in his staff, I thought I'd look into the players that have benefitted from Cignetti's new dynasty at Indiana.
Most people would tell you that the Indiana turnaround was all about Cignetti bringing his best players from James Madison with him. However, only 13 of the 31 incoming transfers to Indiana in 2024 followed Cignetti and his staff. And I'm sure everyone noticed that James Madison has continued to excel with the players that Cignetti left behind so clearly some good players stayed and the cupboard wasn't bare in Harrisonburg. New JMU coach Bob Chesney took much of his staff with him from Holy Cross and there's only one staff member left over from the Cignetti era, so it stands to reason that the Cignetti-coached Dukes remaining at JMU are still very talented. Not only that, but only two Hoosiers were drafted in 2025.













