
The Cignetti Recipe Part 2: The Staff
By Steve Sturm - IlliniGuys Football Analyst
January 23, 2026
(Cover photo courtesy Wide Open Country)
Welcome to Part 2 of the Cignetti Recipe: The Staff.
You may have seen that as a condition of Curt Cignetti's recent in-season extension that he ensured that he would basically have as much money as he wanted to keep whatever staff he wanted. On one hand, that makes sense because a staff is an underrated aspect to a program's success. On the other hand, it's a little surprising to see that Indiana would pay top dollar for the guys that have stuck with Cignetti as he's risen through the ranks. Coordinators Bryant Haines and Mike Shanahan have been with Cignetti at all of his head coaching stops, and the money is Cignetti's attempt to share the wealth since they both started making $10,000 as IUP assistants.
Haines is only 40 years old, and like Cignetti he has a brother in coaching. His brother Tyler is the head coach at DII Catawba. He's a far better communicator than Cignetti and is a future head coaching candidate, so the money helps Cignetti by ensuring that Haines doesn't leave for a head coaching job before he gets a perfect opportunity, not that it stopped Haynes from interviewing for the Michigan job. Shanahan (no relation to the hall of fame coach of the same name) is only 36, and after a brief playing career that included a cup of coffee in the NFL, he took a job at IUP and he's stuck with Cignetti ever since. Shanahan's expertise is with wide receivers and he retains that position coach position at Indiana, but he took the offensive reins at the end of Cignetti's time at James Madison and is still the OC (though Cignetti is very hands-on with the job). He too is a very personable guy and will have a shot at a big-time head coaching job before too long.













