Illini Fall Into Losers Bracket of Big Ten Baseball Tournament Again

A 4-3 defeat to Indiana Wednesday afternoon marked the sixth consecutive loss for Illinois in the Big Ten Tournament in Omaha, Nebraska.

By Matt Stevens - IlliniGuys Staff Writer

May 23, 2023

(Cover photo courtesy Illinois Athletics)

Veteran members of the Illinois baseball program have to begin to feel irritated seeing Charles Schwab Field in Omaha.

Illinois just lost its sixth consecutive game in the Big Ten Baseball Tournament and haven’t been on the winning side of a game in that event since May 25, 2018. The Illini dropped into the losers bracket following a 4-3 defeat at the hands of No. 2 seed Indiana Tuesday afternoon.

“In tight games, to be a really good team, you have to do the little things and we simply didn’t do that today,” Illinois head coach Dan Hartleb said in his WDWS post-game interview. “We talked before this game about not hitting balls in the air because the baseball just doesn’t travel well here and we did exactly that with 13 fly outs.”

Illinois (25-26) got on the board first in the fifth inning thanks to a double to right-center from senior third baseman and leadoff hitter Brandon Comia. The Illini got a spectacular first four innings from junior right-hander Jack Wenninger as the Murray State transfer was able to scatter five hits in his first 70 pitches of an outing on just four days of rest. However, Wenninger (6-4) began to find complications in the fifth inning when a run-scoring single by Hoosiers catcher and ninth hitter Peter Serruto was followed up by back-to-back walks. Indiana (41-16) would take the final lead of the ballgame on a fielder's choice groundout by Big Ten Freshman of the Year selection Devin Taylor. The Hoosiers are projected by both d1baseball.com and Baseball America to be at-large selections when the NCAA Regionals bracket is revealed on Memorial Day afternoon.

Illinois was able to put the tying and go-ahead runs on base in the ninth inning after a throwing error by Hoosiers shortstop Phillip Glasser on what should’ve been the final out of the contest on a routine ground ball by Cam McDonald plated two runs for the Illini. Drake Wescott, who has seven home runs since April 29, could only produce a lazy fly ball to left field to send Illinois into the losers bracket of the league tournament for the third consecutive time (2019, 2022, 2023).

Illinois will try to keep its season alive, as the Illini need to likely win the event to earn the league’s automatic bid to play in NCAA Regionals, when they play Michigan at 7 p.m. CST on Big Ten Network. The Wolverines lost 13-3 to No. 2 seed Iowa earlier in the day in a eight-inning, run-rule contest.

"We competed don’t get me wrong but we got to rebound tomorrow and get it done,” Hartleb said. "This thing is still wide open and we have to go out and compete tomorrow."

Podcasts

Illini Crush Western Michigan - #502

Listen

IlliniGuys Sports Spectacular - $100 Million Donation, Illini Football Update & Canelo vs Crawford S5Ep5 - 9.12.25

Listen

Illinois Football Preview - Western Michigan - #501

Listen

Illini Destroy Duke 45-19 #500

Listen

Illini FB at Duke & Arch Panic - S5Ep4 - 9.5.25

Listen

Illini Football Preview versus Duke - #499

Listen

Illini Destroy Leathernecks 52-3 - #498

Listen

Illini FB is Here, So Is Petrovic & Illini in NFL - S5Ep3 - 8.29.25

Listen

I on the Illini - Western Illinois Preview #497

Listen

Illini FB & BB Updates & Phil Steele on the 2025 Illini FB Season - S5Ep2 - 8.22.25

Listen

1st Show of 5th Season, Illini FB Ranked #12 - S5Ep1 - 8.15.25

Listen

The Top 5 Illini Basketball Coaches in IlliniGuy Memory - #496

Listen

Greg Glass – NIL Primer & Can Fanstake.com Help Attract & Retain Athletic Talent - #495

Listen

Interviews with Bret Bielema, Cam Crocker & Matt Stevens - S4Ep52 - 8.8.25

Listen

Illini FB Coach Bret Bielema Chats with Mike & Rob Louthain Talks NIL & Illini Media - #494

Listen